Public Skepticism Over AI Integration in Journalism
A new report, the Digital News Report published by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, highlights growing public skepticism regarding the use of artificial intelligence (AI) within news reporting. The survey found that when integrating AI into journalism, only 36 per cent of respondents reported feeling comfortable consuming content created by humans with AI assistance. Furthermore, a significantly smaller percentage—just 19 per cent—felt comfortable with news that was primarily AI-generated, even if overseen by human editors.
The report advises news organizations to adopt a cautious approach, noting that while publishers are rapidly adopting AI to increase efficiency and personalize content, the public generally expects human involvement in the editorial process. Experts suggest that AI is best utilized for support functions, such as translation and transcription, rather than replacing journalists entirely.
Widespread Challenges Facing News Consumption
Beyond AI concerns, the report identified several major challenges impacting the media landscape, including elevated levels of news avoidance and general fatigue. Regarding news avoidance, 39 per cent of those surveyed admitted to sometimes or frequently avoiding the news, a substantial increase of 10 percentage points compared to 2019. This represents the highest rate of news avoidance recorded since the report was initially published in 2012.
The Institute suggests that factors contributing to this fatigue include the increased use of smartphones, the constant barrage of push notifications from various applications, and the influence of algorithm-driven platform feeds.
Payment Barriers and Shifting News Platforms
Economically, the report noted that attracting new subscribers remains difficult due to continued reluctance to pay for news, a trend linked to the abundance of free information sources and low general interest. Specifically, only 17 per cent of people surveyed from a basket of 20 wealthier nations reported paying for any online news within the previous year.
Additionally, news consumption is fragmenting across digital platforms. The strong shift toward video-based networks—such as TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram—has increased their importance for news reporting. Weekly news usage statistics show that YouTube is used by nearly 31 per cent of global audiences, followed by WhatsApp at around 21 per cent. TikTok reported 13 per cent usage, having surpassed X (formerly Twitter), which was used by 10 per cent.
Concerns regarding misinformation also rose, increasing by 3 percentage points to 59 per cent. The most significant worries about false or misleading information were directed at topics such as the Israel-Palestine conflict, the Ukraine war, economics, and politics. The report warned that concerns about distinguishing reliable content on online platforms were highest for TikTok and X when compared to other networks.
Local Trends and Trust in Singapore
In Singapore, trust in general news sources saw an increase, reaching 47 per cent in 2024, up from 45 per cent the previous year. The most trusted news brands were identified as The Straits Times, at 73 per cent, and CNA, at 74 per cent.
Regarding reach, The Straits Times maintained the highest offline reach at 36 per cent, followed by CNA at 33 per cent, and Channel 5 at 25 per cent. For online usage, Mothership and CNA were tied as the most used online news websites, each reaching 46 per cent of users weekly. Overall, online and social media remained the primary means of accessing news in Singapore, accounting for 82 per cent and 63 per cent of access, respectively. Conversely, TV and print declined to 46 per cent and 13 per cent, respectively.
Addressing the findings, Professor Edson C. Tandoc Jr., a co-author of the country’s page on the Digital News Report and affiliated with the Wee Kim Wee School of Communication and Information at Nanyang Technological University, observed that readers favor institutional sources. He stated, “Whether it’s generated by AI or not, we find that people trust the story if it’s by one of the legacy brands like ST or CNA.”
Professor Edson added that Singaporeans maintain high trust in mainstream media, noting, “Singaporeans recognise that the mainstream media in Singapore is closely regulated by the Government, but at the same time, the trust is high enough to override the impact of whether it’s AI or human – they still look at the organisation.” He concluded by noting that while some parts of the news production process are being automated, the human author retains ownership of the article.
The Reuters Institute conducted its research by surveying 94,943 adults globally in January and February, which included 2,013 participants from Singapore. The Institute advised that since the survey used a non-random sample, differences of 2 percentage points or less should be interpreted with extreme caution.